original in fr Vincent Renardias
fr to en Georges Tarbouriech
GNU/Linux user since 1993, Vincent Renardias started to get involved in its development in 1996: Debian developer, French translator of The GIMP and GNOME desktop, founder of the Linux User Group in Marseille (PLUG)... Now R&D manager for the EFB2 company, he keeps contributing to GNU/Linux.
This article was first published in a Linux Magazine France special issue focusing on security. The editor, the authors and the translators kindly allowed LinuxFocus to publish every article from this special issue. Accordingly, LinuxFocus will bring them to you as soon as they are translated to English. Thanks to all the people involved in this work. This abstract will be reproduced for each article having the same origin.
One of the good ways to prevent intrusion attempts is to filter what is useless in the network. This task is usually attributed to a machine used as a firewall.
In this article we will present the required basics for implementing and configuring such a system.
The filtering mechanism can be considered as a net which
will stop some unwanted packets. The most important thing is to find
the right size of the mesh and the right place to install
To be able to properly filter the packets, the filtering
mechanism must be physically inserted between the network it
protects and the "rest of the world". Practically this is done
with a machine holding two network interfaces (usually
Ethernet), one connected to the internal network and the other
to the router allowing the access to the outside. This way,
communications will have to go through the firewall which will
block them or not according to their content.
The machine holding the filtering mechanism can be configured in 3 different ways:
- "simple" gateway: this is the most common configuration. The machine is used as a gateway between two networks or subnetworks. The computers in the local network shall be configured to use the firewall instead of the router as their default route.
- "Proxy-ARP" gateway: the previous configuration implies the division of the network into two subnetworks, what makes half the available IP addresses being lost. This is a bit annoying. In the example of a 16 addresses subnetwork (with a 28 bit netmask), only 14 are available, since the network and the broadcast addresses are in use. Adding 1 bit to the subnetmask, we decrease from 14 to only 6 available addresses (8 IPs minus the network and broadcast ones). When you cannot afford to lose half the available IPs, you can use this technique which is explained a bit later in this article. Furthermore, this technique does not require any changes in the network configuration of the existing machines neither the router nor the protected computers.
- Ethernet bridge: installing an Ethernet gateway (not an IP gateway), makes the filtering mechanism invisible from other machines. Such a configuration can be done without assigning IP addresses to the Ethernet interfaces. The machine then becomes undetectable with ping, traceroute, etc. Let us note that a packet filtering implementation in such a configuration requires a 2.2.x kernel since the port of this feature on 2.4.x kernels is not yet finished.
Now that we know where to install our filter, we must define
what it will have to block or what it will have to accept.
There are two ways to configure such a filter:
- The good one: no packet is allowed but the ones a rule accepts.
- The bad one: (unfortunately, often used) the explicitely forbidden packets are stopped, all the others are accepted.
It is simple to explain: in the first case, forgetting a rule results in a service not working properly or not working at all. Usually, this is noticed rather quickly and then it is enough to add the proper rule to make things work again.
In the second case, forgetting a rule creates a potential vulnerability which may be hard to find... if we find it.
The most used packet filtering software with Linux 2.4 is Netfilter; it nicely replaces 'ipchains' used in Linux kernel 2.2. Netfilter is made of two parts: the kernel support which has to be compiled in your kernel and the 'iptables' command that should be available in your system.
A commented example being better than a long speech, next we will describe how to install and setup a filtering mechanism. First, the machine will be configured as a gateway using Proxy-ARP to limit the number of IP addresses and we will setup the filtering system.
The author has a preference for the Debian distribution to setup such a system, but any other distribution will do.
First, check that your kernel has Netfilter support. If this is true, the boot message should contain:
ip_conntrack (4095 buckets, 32760 max)
ip_tables: (c)2000 Netfilter core team
Otherwise, you will have to recompile the kernel after having activated Netfilter support. The corresponding options are found in the "Network Packet Filtering" submenu of the "Networking Options" menu. From the "Netfilter Configuration" section, select the options you need. When in doubt, you can select all of them. Furthermore, it is better to include Netfilter into the kernel and not use modules. If for some reason or other one of the Netfilter modules was missing or not loaded, filtering would not work and we better don't talk about the risks that this would imply.
You also should install the 'iproute2' package (this last is
not compulsory but our example will use it since it allows us to
make the configuration script simpler). With Debian, it is enough to
type the 'apt-get install iproute' command.
With other distributions, get the corresponding package. The usual way or install the software from source code that you can download from the following address:
Now the 2 Ethernet cards have to be configured. We must note
that the Linux kernel, when autodetecting the hardware stops
the search of network cards as soon as it found one.
Accordingly, only the first one is detected.
An easy solution to this problem consists in adding the following line to the lilo.conf file:
Now, we must configure the Ethernet interfaces. The method
we choose allows to use the same IP address for both cards thus
saving one address.
Let us assume that we have a 10.1.2.96/28 subnetwork, that is addresses starting from 10.1.2.96 to 10.1.2.111 included. The router will have the 10.1.2.97 address and our filtering machine the 10.1.2.98. The eth0 interface will be connected to the router through a cross-connect RJ45 cable if both cards are directly connected without using a hub or a switch; the eth1 interface will be connected to the hub/switch and from there to the local network machines.
Accordingly both interfaces will be configured with the following parameters:
address : 10.1.2.98 netmask : 255.255.255.240 network : 10.1.2.96 broadcast: 10.1.2.111 gateway : 10.1.2.97
Next, we use the following script which must be run after
the initial configuration of the network cards to finish the
net.vars: configuration variables PREFIX=10.1.2 DMZ_ADDR=$PREFIX.96/28 # Interface definitions BAD_IFACE=eth0 DMZ_IFACE=eth1 ROUTER=$PREFIX.97 net-config.sh: network configuration script #!/bin/sh # Comment out the next line to display the commands at execution time # set -x # We read the variables defined in the previous file source /etc/init.d/net.vars # We remove the present routes from the local network ip route del $PREFIX.96/28 dev $BAD_IFACE ip route del $PREFIX.96/28 dev $DMZ_IFACE # We define that the local network can be reached through eth1 # and the router through eth0. ip route add $ROUTER dev $BAD_IFACE ip route add $PREFIX.96/28 dev $DMZ_IFACE # We activate Proxy-ARP for both interfaces echo 1 > /proc/sys/net/ipv4/conf/eth0/proxy_arp echo 1 > /proc/sys/net/ipv4/conf/eth1/proxy_arp # We activate the IP forwarding to allow the packets coming to one card # to be routed to the other one. echo 1 > /proc/sys/net/ipv4/ip_forward
Let us go back to the Proxy-ARP mechanism required for our
When a machine talks to another one in the same network, it needs to know the Ethernet address (or MAC address or hardware address) corresponding to its IP address. Then the source machine broadcasts the question "what is the MAC address of the interface having the IP address 188.8.131.52 ?", and the destination machine must answer.
Here is an example of such a "talk" seen using tcpdump:
- the request: the machine 172.16.6.72 asks the MAC address corresponding to the IP address IP 172.16.6.10.
19:46:15.702516 arp who-has 172.16.6.10 tell 172.16.6.72
- the answer: the machine 172.16.6.10 provides its card number.
19:46:15.702747 arp reply 172.16.6.10 is-at 0:a0:4b:7:43:71
This leads us to the end of this short explanation: the ARP requests are done by broadcast, thus being limited to only one physical network. Accordingly the request from a protected machine to find the MAC address of the router should be blocked by the filtering machine. Activating the Proxy-ARP feature allows to solve this problem, since it will transfer the ARP requests.
At this stage, you should have a working network with a machine managing the whole traffic between the local network and the outside.
Now, we must setup the filtering using Netfilter.
Netfilter allows to act directly on the packet flow. In the basic configuration, the packets are managed by 3 rule chains:
- INPUT: for the packets incoming through an interface,
- FORWARD: for all the packets transmitted from an interface to another one,
- OUTPUT: for the packets outgoing through an interface.
The 'iptables' command allows to add, change or remove rules
in each of these chains to modify the filtering behavior.
Furthermore, each chain has a default policy, that is, it knows what to do when no rule in the chain matches a packet.
The four most current options are:
- ACCEPT: the packet is allowed to go through,
- REJECT: the packet is rejected and the associated error packet is sent (ICMP Port Unreachable, TCP RESET, depending on the case),
- LOG: writes a packet note in syslog,
- DROP: the packet is ignored and no answer is sent.
Here are the main options of iptables allowing to manipulate entire chains. We will detail them later on:
-N: creates a new chain.
-X: removes an empty chain.
-P: changes the default policy of a chain.
-L: lists the rules in a chain.
-F: flushes all the rules in a chain.
-Z: clears the bytes and packets counters having gone through the chain.
To modify a chain, the following commands are available:
-A: appends a rule to the end of a chain.
-I: inserts a new rule at a given position in a chain.
-R: replaces a given rule in a chain.
-D: deletes a rule in a chain, either using its number or describing the rule.
Let us see a small practical example: we will block the PING
answers (that is the 'echo-reply' type ICMP packets) coming
from a given machine.
First, let us check that we can "ping" the given machine:
# ping -c 1 172.16.6.74 PING 172.16.6.74 (172.16.6.74): 56 data bytes 64 bytes from 172.16.6.74: icmp_seq=0 ttl=255 time=0.6 ms --- 172.16.6.74 ping statistics --- 1 packets transmitted, 1 packets received, 0% packet loss round-trip min/avg/max = 0.6/0.6/0.6 msNow, we add a rule into the INPUT chain which will intercept the ICMP-Reply ('-p icmp --icmp-type echo-reply') packets coming from the machine 172.16.6.74 ('-s 172.16.6.74'). These packets will be ignored ('-j DROP').
# iptables -A INPUT -s 172.16.6.74 -p icmp --icmp-type echo-reply -j DROP
Now, let us PING this machine again:
# ping -c 3 172.16.6.74 PING 172.16.6.74 (172.16.6.74): 56 data bytes --- 172.16.6.74 ping statistics --- 3 packets transmitted, 0 packets received, 100% packet loss
As we could expect, the answers do not pass. We can check that the 3 answers have been blocked (3 packets for 252 bytes):
# iptables -L INPUT -v Chain INPUT (policy ACCEPT 604K packets, 482M bytes) pkts bytes target prot opt in out source destination 3 252 DROP icmp -- any any 172.16.6.74 anywhere
To go back to the initial situation, we just have to remove the first rule from the INPUT chain:
# iptables -D INPUT 1
Now, PING should work again:
# ping -c 1 172.16.6.74 PING 172.16.6.74 (172.16.6.74): 56 data bytes 64 bytes from 172.16.6.74: icmp_seq=0 ttl=255 time=0.6 ms --- 172.16.6.74 ping statistics --- 1 packets transmitted, 1 packets received, 0% packet loss round-trip min/avg/max = 0.6/0.6/0.6 ms #
It works !
You can add other chains to the 3 pre-existing ones (that you cannot remove anyway) and make some traffic go through them. This can be useful, for instance, to avoid duplicating rules in various chains.
Now, let us setup the required rules for a minimal firewall.
It will allow ssh, domain (DNS), http and smtp services and
To simplify, the setup commands are written in a shell script to make configuration easier. The script starts flushing out the present configuration before setting up the new one. This small trick allows the script to be run when the configuration is active without the risk of duplicated rules.
rc.firewall #!/bin/sh # Flushing out the rules iptables -F iptables -F INPUT iptables -F OUTPUT iptables -F FORWARD # The chain is built according to the direction. # bad = eth0 (outside) # dmz = eth1 (inside) iptables -X bad-dmz iptables -N bad-dmz iptables -X dmz-bad iptables -N dmz-bad iptables -X icmp-acc iptables -N icmp-acc iptables -X log-and-drop iptables -N log-and-drop # Specific chain used for logging packets before blocking them iptables -A log-and-drop -j LOG --log-prefix "drop " iptables -A log-and-drop -j DROP # The packets having the TCP flags activated are dropped # and so for the ones with no flag at all (often used with Nmap scans) iptables -A FORWARD -p tcp --tcp-flags ALL ALL -j log-and-drop iptables -A FORWARD -p tcp --tcp-flags ALL NONE -j log-and-drop # The packets coming from reserved addresses classes are dropped # and so for multicast iptables -A FORWARD -i eth+ -s 184.108.40.206/4 -j log-and-drop iptables -A FORWARD -i eth+ -s 192.168.0.0/16 -j log-and-drop iptables -A FORWARD -i eth+ -s 172.16.0.0/12 -j log-and-drop iptables -A FORWARD -i eth+ -s 10.0.0.0/8 -j log-and-drop # The packets belonging to an already established connexion are accepted iptables -A FORWARD -m state --state INVALID -j log-and-drop iptables -A FORWARD -m state --state RELATED,ESTABLISHED -j ACCEPT # The corresponding chain is sent according to the packet origin iptables -A FORWARD -s $DMZ_ADDR -i $DMZ_IFACE -o $BAD_IFACE -j dmz-bad iptables -A FORWARD -o $DMZ_IFACE -j bad-dmz # All the rest is ignored iptables -A FORWARD -j log-and-drop # Accepted ICMPs iptables -A icmp-acc -p icmp --icmp-type destination-unreachable -j ACCEPT iptables -A icmp-acc -p icmp --icmp-type source-quench -j ACCEPT iptables -A icmp-acc -p icmp --icmp-type time-exceeded -j ACCEPT iptables -A icmp-acc -p icmp --icmp-type echo-request -j ACCEPT iptables -A icmp-acc -p icmp --icmp-type echo-reply -j ACCEPT iptables -A icmp-acc -j log-and-drop # Outside -> Inside chain # mail, DNS, http(s) and SSH are accepted iptables -A bad-dmz -p tcp --dport smtp -j ACCEPT iptables -A bad-dmz -p udp --dport domain -j ACCEPT iptables -A bad-dmz -p tcp --dport domain -j ACCEPT iptables -A bad-dmz -p tcp --dport www -j ACCEPT iptables -A bad-dmz -p tcp --dport https -j ACCEPT iptables -A bad-dmz -p tcp --dport ssh -j ACCEPT iptables -A bad-dmz -p icmp -j icmp-acc iptables -A bad-dmz -j log-and-drop # Inside -> Outside chain # mail, DNS, http(s) and telnet are accepted iptables -A dmz-bad -p tcp --dport smtp -j ACCEPT iptables -A dmz-bad -p tcp --sport smtp -j ACCEPT iptables -A dmz-bad -p udp --dport domain -j ACCEPT iptables -A dmz-bad -p tcp --dport domain -j ACCEPT iptables -A dmz-bad -p tcp --dport www -j ACCEPT iptables -A dmz-bad -p tcp --dport https -j ACCEPT iptables -A dmz-bad -p tcp --dport telnet -j ACCEPT iptables -A dmz-bad -p icmp -j icmp-acc iptables -A dmz-bad -j log-and-drop # Chains for the machine itself iptables -N bad-if iptables -N dmz-if iptables -A INPUT -i $BAD_IFACE -j bad-if iptables -A INPUT -i $DMZ_IFACE -j dmz-if # External interface # SSH only accepted on this machine iptables -A bad-if -p icmp -j icmp-acc iptables -A bad-if -p tcp --dport ssh -j ACCEPT iptables -A bad-if -p tcp --sport ssh -j ACCEPT ipchains -A bad-if -j log-and-drop # Internal interface iptables -A dmz-if -p icmp -j icmp-acc iptables -A dmz-if -j ACCEPT
A few words on the quality of service. Linux can modify the ToS ("Type of Service") field and change its value to give the packet a different priority. For instance, the following command changes the outgoing SSH packets to improve the connecion response.
iptables -A OUTPUT -t mangle -p tcp --dport ssh -j TOS --set-tos Minimize-Delay
In the same way, for FTP connecions you could use the '--set-tos Maximize-Throughput' option, to improve the transfer rate to the detriment of the session interactivity.
That's it. Now, you know the basics to setup an efficient
packet filtering system. However, keep in mind that a firewall
is not the panacea when security is a concern. It only is
another precaution. Setting up a firewall does not prevent you
from using strong passwords, latest security patches, intrusion
detection system, etc.